Crouch End Festival Chorus
The Chorus History Concert Calendar News and Reviews Contact Us Recordings People Links
News and Reviews

Return to homepage

 

Crouch End Festival Chorus
Kirov Orchestra conducted by Valery Gergiev
Royal Albert Hall (Prom 50)
28 August 2001

Wagner - Die Meistersinger (extract)
Schoenberg - Pelleas and Melisande
Skryabin - Prometheus: The Poem of Fire (this is the part we sang in!)
Wagner - Die Walkure (extract)

BY Barry Millington (Times)

IDEALLY, the programme informed us, the composer would have liked the audience to be clad in white robes. Scriabin’s Prometheus: The Poem of Fire was intended as part of a massive project called Mysterium: a son et lumière spectacular fusing the arts and involving a “colour organ”. The Proms have been experimenting with coloured lights throughout the season, but for Prometheus they came at last into their own.

Purples, reds and other lights played on the stage area throughout the score, and as the final F sharp major affirmation rang round the hall, the direction for the colour organ — pearly blue, the colour of moonlight — was realised. At that point, too, the audience, strafed by spotlights, did indeed appear to be clad in white. It was quite a coup and given the power of Valery Gergiev’s performance with the Kirov Orchestra, ably assisted by the Crouch End Festival Chorus, the total effect was properly overwhelming.

The opening of the tone poem evokes a primordial cosmos before the heroic act of Prometheus bringing fire to mankind. Gergiev caught the languorous atmosphere here and weaved a sumptuous carpet of sound with his players. He took care, however, to ensure that all the threads were in place, allowing the prominent trumpet lines, among others, to make their mark. The eccentricities of pianist Alexander Toradze were eclipsed by the grandiose eccentricity of the whole, though his feral grunts were still audible from the far side of the hall.

Gergiev’s dynamic yet fluid approach was also eminently successful for Schoenberg’s massive tone poem Pelleas und Melisande. The onward rush, verging on breathlessness, is balanced by purposeful punctuation, and there is room in his reading for both light, skittish episodes (Melisande playing with her ring) and for sombre statements emanating out of the Stygian gloom.

Framing these two scores were Wagnerian extracts from The Mastersingers (a sensuous Act III Prelude) and Die Walküre (Wotan’s Farewell and the Magic Fire music). Gergiev’s Wagner is vibrant, invigorating and heady, though as he showed in the glowing final pages of Die Walküre, he can also draw from the Kirov a tone of smouldering warmth and amplitude. Vladimir Vaneev, a Kirov Opera principal, sang the part of Wotan with musicality, but in a light baritone far removed from the heroic bass baritone envisaged by Wagner.

Thanks to The Times for this review.