Crouch End Festival Chorus
The Chorus History Concert Calendar News and Reviews Contact Us Recordings People Links
News and Reviews

Return to homepage

 

Crouch End Festival Chorus
Kirov Orchestra conducted by Valery Gergiev
Royal Albert Hall (Prom 50)
28 August 2001

Wagner - Die Meistersinger (extract)
Schoenberg - Pelleas und Melisande
Skryabin - Prometheus: The Poem of Fire (this is the part we sang in!)
Wagner - Die Walkure (extract)

BY Richard Fairman (Financial Times)

The August bank holiday weekend has become a high point in the BBC Proms summer calendar. As they crowd the airports on the way out of the country, British holidaymakers should not be surprised to find themselves elbowing their way through an army of cellos, double-basses and trombones on the way in.

On Tuesday it was the turn of the Kirov Orchestra under Valery Gergiev. Here was the antithesis of the Japanese visitors, an orchestra that invariably gives the impression of flying by the seat of its pants, but has expressiveness deep in its bones. Never one to miss an opportunity, Gergiev delivered a programme of super-romantic monstrosities.

Schoenberg's Pelleas und Melisande received a splendidly flamboyant performance, though the Kirov's fine brass section was granted unlimited dominance in its raised position at the back of the stage. Skryabin's Prometheus: The Poem of Fire,a gargantuan tone-poem big on ideas but modest on achievement, threw together Alexander Toradze's noisy piano solo, the Crouch End Festival Chorus and a half-hearted light display. Turning the Albert Hall organ pink hardly matches Skryabin's call for a dazzling transcendental light at the end.

Then Vladimir Vaneyev was the rather pale baritone soloist in Wotan's Farewell from Wagner's Die Walkure -more fire music to ensure complete conflagration by the end of the evening. At least Gergiev was on his usual heated form and his orchestra performs marvels trying to keep up with him. A shame that the hall was far from full. Maybe word of the Kirov's less-than-successful Verdi season at the Royal Opera House earlier in the summer had got around.

Thanks to the FT for this review.